It’s not that I fear wikipedia, it’s that I’ve been taught (brain washed) into not even acknowledging the use of it while doing historical research. In most of my undergraduate classes the professor would even put in the syllabus that use of wikipedia for research was not acceptable. And in the Anthropology department they went so far as to threaten being kicked out of a class. But it also seems to me that every time I do try and give wiki a chance I am disappointed in the result. For example I had to give a presentation in my class today on Perry Miller, while doing research I decided to give wiki a chance. For the most part the information in the biography were correct. There was this paragraph thought detailing an account that Miller had been in a relationship with one of his graduate students, got into a fight with another professor over it, etc. When I questioned my professor (who knows the life of Perry Miller like the back of her hand) she stated she had never heard that story. And just when I was so close to giving wiki a shot!
I’m not going to completely bash wiki even though I will state now that I will probably never use it when doing historical research, but it does have it’s positive aspects. It’s amazing how much information and topics are located on wiki, I have searched everyday stuff that I’m interested in knowing. Like when I heard of a foreign game my friends in Plymouth use to play called Kubb, I looked it up and learned the rules so that when I got to play I understood the game. It’s for sure an invention that we will all use at one time or another.
I’ve been trying to break this horrible habit I’ve had since freshman year of high school known as procrastination. But how am I to do that when the Internet has made everything so easily accessible! So I have a quick report due in the morning and it’s midnight, jump on a search engine, do a couple hours of reading and typing and tada I have a complete and informative paper! The Internet has made life easier in so many other ways, but are we doing ourselves a disservice? Honestly I think that one has to curb the amount of on line research and still go with the old fashion way of checking out books at the library! The feeling of satisfaction of finding something over a database versus holding that dusty, crinkled document in your hand is in no way similar. When you make a big find, and it’s right there in your hands, words cannot describe the feeling that comes over you. We as historians have to learn how to use all resources that are available to us for research, no matter how big of pain in the ass it is to carry 8 books in your backpack!
Sarah~